POLL: Closed or open?

Which do you prefer, closed or open pineapple tarts? DS likes open ones, DD likes closed ones, I like pineapple tarts. I like these from my friend who's making them this year.

I tried some this year! Soft buttery exterior that crumbles easily, filled with pineapple and fruit peel, or at least that's what I think it is. I like pineapple tarts tangy and these are certainly it!

Or if you like something crunchier that's a hit with younger ones, try these. With nuts and raisins.